This Day in American History: Lincoln Challenges Douglas to Debate
- ForAmerica
- 19 hours ago
- 2 min read
On this day in 1858, a little-known Illinois lawyer challenged the most powerful senator in the country to a series of debates that would change the trajectory of American history.
By the summer of 1858, Abraham Lincoln and Senator Stephen A. Douglas were crisscrossing Illinois giving competing speeches, sometimes trailing each other from town to town, in a bitter fight for Douglas's Senate seat. On July 24, 1858, Lincoln sent Douglas a formal letter proposing something more direct: "Will it be agreeable to you to make an arrangement for you and myself to divide time, and address the same audience during the present canvass?" Douglas wrote back the same day agreeing, on the condition that he would pick the times and locations.
Douglas named seven towns, one in each of Illinois's congressional districts where the two men hadn't already crossed paths that summer, and the two campaigns hammered out the details over the following week. What resulted was seven debates held between August 21 and October 15, 1858, in Ottawa, Freeport, Jonesboro, Charleston, Galesburg, Quincy, and Alton -- drawing enormous crowds, sometimes in the tens of thousands, to hear the two men argue almost exclusively over one question: whether slavery should be allowed to expand into America's western territories.
Douglas championed "popular sovereignty," the idea that each territory's own settlers should vote on whether to allow slavery. Lincoln argued that slavery's expansion had to be stopped outright, framing the fight in moral terms that went well beyond ordinary political calculation. Douglas ultimately won reelection to the Senate that November, but Lincoln's performance in the debates -- reprinted in newspapers across the country -- made him a national figure. Two years later, the two men faced off again, this time for the presidency, and Lincoln won.
Also on this day:
1847 -- Brigham Young leads Mormon pioneers into Utah's Salt Lake Valley, founding what would become Salt Lake City.
1866 -- Tennessee becomes the first Confederate state readmitted to the Union after the Civil War.
1959 -- Vice President Richard Nixon and Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev spar in the famous "Kitchen Debate" in Moscow.
1969 -- Apollo 11 splashes down safely in the Pacific Ocean, completing America's first crewed mission to the Moon.
1974 -- The Supreme Court unanimously rules that President Nixon must turn over the Watergate tapes.
1983 -- George Brett's pine-tar home run against the Yankees is disallowed, sparking one of baseball's most famous meltdowns.
One letter, seven debates, and a national reputation built town square by town square -- proof that in America, an underdog with the right argument can still change everything.
Source: Papers of Abraham Lincoln, Library of Congress
Comments